The 3-2-1 Backup Rule for Photographers (And a Simpler Version)

What 3-2-1 backup means in plain English, a setup that costs under $500, the version I actually use, and the one step every guide skips.

Megan Smith and the HeyShutter team 8 min read Published
Guide 2 of 2 in Workflow & Backup
On this page 10 sections
  1. What 3-2-1 means
  2. Why each number is there
  3. A 3-2-1 setup under $500
  4. The step every guide skips: checking
  5. The simpler version I actually use
  6. Drives vs cloud: the honest version
  7. What to back up (and what not to)
  8. A 3-2-1 checklist
  9. Quick answers
  10. Make the bad day boring
HeyShutter graphic: The 3-2-1 Backup Rule for Photographers (And a Simpler Version)

Every backup guide for photographers starts with the 3-2-1 rule, and most of them end with a $5,000 pile of RAID drives and a sentence like "I won’t get into the technical details." I read those for years, nodded, and kept all my client photos on one external drive with a sticker that said MAIN. The sticker did not help when it died.

So here is 3-2-1 the way I wish someone had explained it: what it means, why the numbers are what they are, a setup that costs less than a lens, the simpler version I actually run now, and the step every guide skips (it is not buying another drive).

What 3-2-1 means

Three numbers, one sentence each.

3 copies. The photo exists in 3 places. The original plus 2 backups. Not 3 copies on one drive. Three separate things.

2 different kinds of storage. Not 3 identical hard drives from the same box, bought the same day, that will fail the same week. Different kinds: a drive and the cloud, a drive and a card, a laptop and a drive.

1 copy somewhere else. Not your house. A fire, a flood, a burglar, or a spilled coffee takes everything in one room. One copy has to be in a different building.

That is the whole rule. It was written for IT departments, but it fits photographers perfectly because our whole business is a pile of files that cannot be recreated.

Why each number is there

It helps to know what each number protects against, because then you can tell if your own setup actually has it.

NumberProtects against
3 copiesA drive dying. Drives die. Every one of them, eventually.
2 kindsA bad batch, a bad cable, a virus, or a mistake that hits every drive of the same kind at once
1 off siteFire, flood, theft, or a power surge that takes out everything in the room

Now check yours. "The card and my laptop" is 2 copies, 2 kinds, 0 off site. "Two drives on my desk" is 2 copies, 1 kind, 0 off site. Most photographers I talk to are at 2-1-0 and feel fine until the day they are not.

A 3-2-1 setup under $500

You do not need RAID. You do not need a server. Here is a setup for a working portrait or wedding photographer with about 1.5 TB of new files a year.

Copy 1: your working drive. A 2 TB external SSD plugged into your computer. This is where you edit from. About $150.

Copy 2: a second drive you only use for backup. A 4 TB spinning hard drive (slower, cheaper, fine for backup). Once a week, or every time you finish a shoot, a backup app copies everything new from copy 1 to copy 2. About $100. Keep it in a drawer, not plugged in all the time.

Copy 3: the cloud. Every file also goes to cloud storage. This is your off site copy and your different kind. $200 to $300 a year depending on how much you keep.

Total for year one: about $450 to $550. Year two and after: the cloud cost, plus a new drive every 3 years or so.

That is 3 copies (SSD, HDD, cloud), 2 kinds (local drives and cloud), 1 off site (cloud). Done.

The step every guide skips: checking

Here is the thing nobody tells you. A backup you have never checked is a hope, not a backup.

Two ways backups fail quietly:

The copy did not actually happen. The app said "done," but a folder was skipped, a cable dropped, or the drive was full. You find out when you need the file.

The copy is damaged. A file copied fine but one in every few hundred got corrupted on the way. The file exists, the size looks right, and it will not open.

The fix for both is verification: comparing every copied file to the original, byte by byte, and reporting what matched. Good backup apps do this. Drag and drop does not. "Sync" tools usually do not. And some cloud uploads do not, which means the thing you are paying to protect you may be the thing that failed.

Ask of every piece of your backup: does it tell me the copy was checked? If the answer is no, you have a 3-2-1 setup that might be a 2-1-0 setup, and you will not know until the bad day.

This is why I stopped formatting cards until something had checked the copy. The when to format a memory card post is the short version of that rule.

The simpler version I actually use

After a few years of the drives and the drawer and the weekly ritual, I changed to something with fewer parts. It is still 3-2-1. It just gets there faster.

Copy 1: the card. During the shoot, both camera slots write the same RAW. Two cards, same files.

Copy 2 and 3: a verified cloud offload, before I leave the venue. I plug the card into my laptop and offload straight to HeyShutter Drive. Every file uploads to private cloud storage and is checked against the card. When it says "checked 100%," the photo is in the cloud (off site, different kind) and still on 2 cards (local). That is 3 copies, 2 kinds, 1 off site, before I drive home.

Then: the cards get formatted only after the cloud copy is verified. Culling and editing happen from a local copy pulled from the cloud, or straight from the cloud if I am traveling. Finished JPEGs go to the client gallery, which is more cloud storage.

What I gave up: the drawer of drives, the weekly backup app, and the "did it actually run?" worry.

What it costs: $20 per TB a month, or $200 per TB a year. For my 1.5 TB a year:

Drive comes in whole TB, so 1.5 TB means the 2 TB plan: 2 x $200 = $400 a year

Roughly what the drives cost, except nothing in a drawer can fail and every file is checked. The on location backup post walks through the exact routine at a venue.

Drives vs cloud: the honest version

I am not anti drive. I am anti "only drives." Here is how they compare for the 3 jobs.

External drivesCloud
Fast to edit fromYesNo (pull a local copy first)
Off siteNo, unless you carry one to your mom’s house every weekYes, by default
Checks the copyOnly with a good backup appDepends on the service. Drive does. Many do not.
FailsEvery 3 to 5 years, usually without warningData centers have their own backups
Cost over 5 years, 1.5 TB/year2 to 3 drives, $300 to $500, plus your timeAbout $2,000 at $200 per TB per year
Lost in a house fireYesNo

Cloud is more money over 5 years. It is also the only one of the two that is actually off site and actually checked without you doing anything. The cloud backup comparison covers Backblaze, Dropbox, and gallery storage side by side, and the do photographers still need hard drives post makes the case for keeping one as your fast working copy.

What to back up (and what not to)

Back up:

  • Every RAW file from a paid shoot, including rejects, until the gallery is delivered. Cull after backup, never before.
  • The finished JPEGs, forever or close to it. They are small and clients come back years later.
  • Your editing catalog (Lightroom catalog or the equivalent). It is your edits. Losing it means re editing.
  • Contracts, client lists, and your website files.

Do not bother:

  • RAW rejects after the gallery is delivered and sold. Keep the selects, let the rest go after a year.
  • Software installers and things you can download again.

The how long to keep client photos post has the retention policy by genre.

A 3-2-1 checklist

Run through this once. If any line is a no, that is the hole.

  • ☐ Every shoot is in 3 places within 24 hours of shooting
  • ☐ At least one of those is not a hard drive (cloud or card)
  • ☐ At least one is in a different building
  • ☐ Something checks the copies and tells me they matched
  • ☐ I format cards only after a verified copy exists
  • ☐ Finished JPEGs are kept somewhere I can get to in 5 years
  • ☐ I have actually restored a file from each backup to prove it works
  • ☐ My editing catalog is backed up too

That last restore test is the one people skip. Pick a random file from last year. Get it back from each copy. If you cannot, you learned something today instead of on the worst day.

Quick answers

What is the 3-2-1 backup rule for photographers?
Three copies of every photo, on two different kinds of storage, with one copy somewhere other than your house.

Do I need RAID for photo backup?
No. RAID protects against one drive in a box dying. It does not protect against fire, theft, or a mistake that wipes the box. A drive plus the cloud does more for less.

Is cloud storage enough for photo backup?
Cloud plus the card or a local drive is a complete 3-2-1 setup. Cloud alone is 1 copy, which is not a backup.

How do I know my backup actually worked?
Use a tool that verifies the copy against the original and tells you. Then restore a file once to prove it.

Make the bad day boring

A good backup plan is not about having the most drives. It is about the day a drive dies, or a card fails, or the house floods, being a shrug instead of a crisis. Three copies, two kinds, one somewhere else, and something that checks the copies.

If you want the checked, off site copy to happen the moment you plug in a card, that is what HeyShutter Drive does. Offload, verify every file, and format when it says it is safe. Free for 14 days with 50 GB and no card needed. Try it on your next shoot.

Was this guide useful?